Showing posts with label Trafficking. Show all posts
Showing posts with label Trafficking. Show all posts

Thursday, August 23, 2012

Sometimes the so called Rescuer is the one who needs to be Rescued


Who do you know that walks around bragging about how they have been “rescued.”  
What healthy and happy individual ever hopes to be referred to as a “victim.”  I cannot help but wonder if these very terms meant to demonstrate innocence (or lack of fault) could be complicating an already complex situation. 

I respect many individuals and organizations that are working in this arena.  This is not a rant against anyone. I only bring this up because I shudder when I hear the words victim and rescue over and over and over. At times it even seems to be re-exploitation. Using the words, stories and experiences of someone else to raise a dollar or gain attention.

Every one of us is moving forward.  We get nowhere dwelling on our past.  We know it is not something to be ignored but neither should it be our sole focus.  A girl or boy, man or woman that has dealt with trauma does not need to be reminded of every painful memory on the walls around them.  In the newspapers, or in books.  They don’t need to hear their story told over and over with these words as key.  They should not have to tell their story over and over.  There is a time and a place to address these issues and it is not in the eye of the public.  On display for “the rest of us.”  It is not through social media or campaigning. This is an area for professionals.  This is the time for committed, seasoned, and culturally knowledgeable experts.  This is just my personal experience - not a professional opinion by any means.

I hear presentations or see passionate films meant to induce empathy and funds and over and over I wince at the constant use of these words.  Victim.   Rescue. 

Definition of “Rescue” according to Merriam Webster:

to free from confinement, danger, or evil : save, deliver as

a : to take (as a prisoner) forcibly from custody

b : to recover (as a prize) by force

c : to deliver (as a place under siege) by armed force

If I were truly “rescued” from a horrendous situation as these films, books, websites, etc. imply I would feel greatly indebted to the person or people who rescued me.  Especially as a wounded and traumatized individual, that word thrown around over and over and over could cause feelings of deep obligation.  

To free someone from danger, to save or deliver them.  That is a massive task.  I do not think this could really be happening as often as it is being implied.  Rather it almost seems as if  people are just trying to be heroes.  

There are countless organizations and groups with the term Rescue in their name.  The word is used on their websites, at their conferences, in face to face conversation, in their brochures….everywhere.  It is a part of them.  A part of their foundation.  To them it is a piece of their existence.  Is it affecting their approach?

But what if there is more.  What about the girls and boys who need to move beyond this.  What about the women who are learning worth, value, significance.  NOT learning from someone who has ‘rescued’ them, not learning from their surroundings.  But finding the worth that is inherent in their very beings. 

Many of us have been "victims."  But we do not ask people to refer to us that way.  
W do not need to have the world know.  I do not wish to be referred to as “rescued’ “saved” “delivered” or “freed.”  Maybe others do not wish it either.

These words seem to connotate some kind of Supreme Being.  




Just the first half of the first page of Google search for rescue, trafficking







Sunday, August 12, 2012

why can't there just be a middle ground?


There is a distinct line when it comes to the issue of trafficking.   It seems you are on one side or the other.  People vehemently defend their chosen side.  Why does this issue have to be so controversial? 

While it is difficult to argue the existence of trafficking, there are still some who would fight even the use of the term.  While many of the statistics surrounding the issue are questionable and thrown around carelessly, it is happening at some level on all continents (um except Antarctica).  It is something that should not be ignored.  Labor trafficking does not seem to arouse quite the amount of passion as “sex trafficking.”  Recently it seems it is sex trafficking that has so much attention and that is what I have been thinking about. 

What I question is not it’s existence. 
What I question is the focus of people’s passion. 
I know I have swung back and forth across ‘the line.’   
But why does it have to be so BLACK & WHITE, CUT & DRIED.  
Why does it seem like I have to choose to be either a Bible thumping missionary or an advocate for legalized prostitution? 
Why do I have to choose between praying for women or paying them for services?

Where is the happy medium?  I have met and respect people on both sides of the (invisible) line.  I just wish some of us could live in the middle without being judged by both. 

Every day I learn something new.  Next year my thoughts on this issue may have made a 180” turn.  I don’t know.  What I know is that I am neither a missionary nor a supporter of paying for sex.  But I’m not an expert.  It is up to you to have your opinion, your beliefs, please let me have mine too.  We have all had different experiences and have a right to our own opinion. 

Let me be free.  Let me revel in the knowledge that there are many, many experts out there doing an amazing job.  There are painstaking research tactics being conducted as I type.  I will continue to read, learn and study.   I will learn from them.  I will continue to meet the actual citizens of this place we all like to “label” and form opinions of.  Continue to learn about their own journeys and challenges.  My own opinions will evolve.  Just like these issues continually evolve. 

But don’t believe that everyone thinks like you.  Don’t even believe that everyone SHOULD think like you.

Why can’t we have meaningful conversations without overheating?  Without excess opinion but with relevant and trustworthy facts. 

Ya, ya I know it’s a “hot topic” and the latest celebrity trend.  I know it’s a sore subject for many.  But we can’t be judging and offending and criticizing the true advocates.  The ones who were there before it was trendy. 

You know what…
I can give out condoms while wishing, hoping and yes praying for the best. 
I can meditate and receive a blessing from a Buddhist monk without “going to hell”. 
I can care for and befriend the girls at the bars, the men at the bars, the ladyboys, pretty much anyone and that is ok too.

I’m not a missionary.  And I am not here to “save” anyone.  Haha as if.  

And I’m not an advocate for the sex industry.  I know it’s always been around.  I know it’s a part of culture and it isn’t my place to change someone else’s culture.


Just trying to figure out how to be in the middle.
How to let people know that not everyone is coming with one or the other.
Money and an agenda or a bible and an agenda.  


Thursday, May 6, 2010

The things that we don't always think about...

In light of immigration laws...
(from the 'end human trafficking website')

Many human trafficking victims are undocumented immigrants. Some enter the U.S. legally and willingly, but their immigration status expires after they are enslaved. Others enter illegally and unwillingly, smuggled in by traffickers. Some victims are forced to travel to the U.S. through legal means (like fake marriages) and others are voluntarily smuggled, only to find themselves in slavery after they arrive. But the new requirements of the Arizona law won't help identify human human trafficking victims and get them to safety. They'll actually hurt that effort.

Human trafficking victims are victims of a crime, regardless of their immigration status, and many of them have suffered severe physical and emotional trauma during the course of their captivity. When victims come into contact with law enforcement, it is critically important that they are treated as victims as opposed to criminals.

Traffickers will often convince victims that police officers will arrest them if they are in the country illegally, and not believe their stories of force or coercion. This law promises to make the traffickers' threats true. It promises to train all law enforcement people to look at potential undocumented immigrants as criminals and people doing something "illegal" first, and not as victims. The fact is that this law is going to up the chances that undocumented trafficking victims end up detained or deported and documented traffickers walk free.

And it's not just trafficking victims who will be affected. Undocumented immigrant victims of domestic violence or child abuse may be less likely to come forward and seek help under the new Arizona law. Currently, there are specific immigration remedies available to immigrant victims of abuse, including providing them with legal immigration status, which the law doesn't change. But the law does change the level of fear of law enforcement and the legal system immigrants may feel, and possibly be one more barrier for victims of human trafficking and abuse from coming forward.